Book Review on Alistair Campbell's Living Better
I knew of Alastair Campbell mainly from the Blair years and a little from his more recent work, especially the podcast he co-hosts with Rory Stewart (The Rest is Politics). I’m a big fan of Rory; Alastair I’m still undecided about. I try not to write negatively on my blog, and I think he’d understand my lack of certainty – to be honest, I think he might agree with it.
He openly admits he isn’t the easiest person to live with. His partner Fiona says he’s difficult but never boring, and he, in return, describes her as organised, dependable, and a bit boring – which I can’t help but feel is a bit mean. That caustic side to him does crop up, including in his writing and podcast, and it’s not my favourite quality. But no one ever said that having mental health challenges automatically makes you easy-going or saintly!
What I admire – genuinely – is his openness. He writes with raw honesty about his experiences of depression and his relationship with alcohol. As a young journalist, his drinking was spiralling out of control and was one of the key factors that led to a psychotic episode. It was a major turning point and perhaps the beginning of his long and ongoing journey towards recovery. (Though he is candid that depression is something that he has to live with and won’t be cured).
For those who know me, you’ll understand why I tend to be compassionate and interested when it comes to mental health. Even so, this book gave me new insights. I found it especially fascinating how he scores his depression – something I hadn’t come across before – and how rapidly it can overwhelm him without warning or clear cause. He’s clearly done his research too, discussing various therapies and counselling approaches in a way that’s informed and grounded. He explores the benefits (and limits) of medication and reflects on the toll his illness has taken on those around him. There’s a longing for family harmony and stability in his writing, but I wasn’t always convinced he fully grasps what his family goes through – and yes, I do wish he showed a bit more gratitude in places.
Campbell also opens up about mental health across his wider family. He doesn’t hold back – from the tragedy of a childhood friend’s suicide to the resilience of his brother, who lives with schizophrenia and found real purpose through music. Donald Campbell became the official piper at the University of Glasgow, where he worked for nearly three decades.
One of the book’s strengths lies in its structure. The chapters are clearly signposted so you can dip in and focus on particular aspects of mental health, whether that’s therapy, diagnosis, family, addiction, or recovery. It makes it very readable – even for someone like me who finds non-fiction challenging!
Will I become a Campbell superfan? Probably not. But will I keep listening to The Rest is Politics and weighing up his opinions? Probably yes.
If you’re after a mental health memoir that’s approachable, layered, and not afraid to be messy, this is well worth a read. And if you get the chance to visit Barter Books and pick up something special for yourself, do it. It’s the kind of place that feels like a story waiting to happen.
Book Club Questions on Alastair Campbell's Living Better
1. Campbell uses a personal scale to rate his depression daily. How effective do you think this method is for managing or communicating mental health?
2. The chapters are clearly signposted. Did this help you approach the topics with more focus or pick and choose what felt most relevant to you?
3. How does the portrayal of Campbell’s relationship with his family shape your understanding of living with depression?
4. What do you make of Campbell’s reflections on alcoholism as a young journalist? How does that shape your view of his breakdown and recovery?
5. Do you think Campbell is sufficiently appreciative of the support he receives from others, particularly his partner Fiona?
6. Were you surprised by the level of knowledge he has about medication and therapy? Did it change or reinforce your own views?
7. How does the book challenge stereotypes about people in the public eye discussing mental health?
8. Did the inclusion of family stories – especially his brother’s and childhood friend’s – help make the memoir feel more honest or was too much information shared?
9. What was one moment or section that stayed with you long after you put the book down?
10. Would you recommend Living Better to someone currently struggling with their mental health, or someone supporting a loved one?
Book Club Questions on Living Better (For if you haven't read the book)
1.
Alastair Campbell is known as a tough political
figure. How does that influence your expectations of a personal memoir on
mental health?
2.
What does “living better” mean to you
personally? Does the title suggest gradual change, hope, or something else?
3.
Campbell’s relationship with his partner is
described as complex but supportive. How important is honesty in relationships
when dealing with mental health?
4.
If someone in the public eye shares something
deeply personal like this, does it make you more likely to engage with their
views on other topics?
5.
Do you think people who write about mental
health have a responsibility to be optimistic, realistic, or neither?
6.
How does reading (or hearing about) someone
else’s experience with depression change your understanding of it?
7.
What kinds of stories or perspectives do you
wish were more visible in conversations about mental health?
8.
Have you ever visited a place like Barter Books
– and did you find something unexpected or special there?