Book Review on Sarah Winman's Tin Man
The story revolves around three main characters: Michael, Ellis, and Annie. Ellis is, I suppose, arguably the central character, but they are a trio. In this respect, it reminds me very much of a book I read by Julian Barnes, Talking It Over (another good read), where a love triangle develops. In Tin Man, there isn’t a physical love triangle—Michael is openly gay—but there is a mutual emotional dependency between them all.
When we are first introduced to the characters, they are boys. Ellis dreams of being an artist, but ends up working in a car plant. Michael moves to the area and is brought up by his grandmother, Mabel. The book is about love, and it’s about character. It is tender, subtle, and deals with the emotions we all face in life: grief, memory, art, beauty, repression, and openness.
A key feature in the book is a print of Van Gogh’s Sunflowers, which is significant in Ellis’s mum’s life and ultimately becomes a symbol of joy and hope amid sadness. As I write, I’ve realised that this is probably a nod to Van Gogh himself. Art featured heavily in Still Life — the book that led me to become interested in Winman — with a focus on Renaissance art. In interviews, Sarah Winman speaks about how art enables her characters (and her readers) to process grief, love, and joy. I particularly like how she lifts ordinary people through their appreciation of art, showing how it transcends class, if you like.
Tin Man isn’t really plot-driven, other than following the characters’ lives and how they respond to illness. The AIDS epidemic is present—quietly but powerfully—and we see the emotional and physical toll it takes, especially on Michael. I suppose, as it is written in 2017, the looking back at recent history adds to the melancholy. It’s a bit like reading an old comic or watching a TV show set in the 1980s or 1990s. Winman captures the mood, atmosphere, and setting of that time in history with ease.
From the working-class grit of Ellis’s dad at the car plant to Michael’s cold, unaccepting mother, the sense of place is strong. The romance of the road trip to rural France, the freedom of Brighton where Michael later lives, and the community of the Oxford village which Michael stops visiting once Mabel has died — all these settings contribute to the emotional map of the book.
This book isn’t pacey or fast; it’s gentle, warm, and sad. It’s a bit like Anne Tyler’s Three Days in June in some ways, but more dreamy and ephemeral. Yet they could work side by side as part of a similar genre. I enjoyed both. And I look forward to reading more. Tin Man is simpler than Still Life by a long way, less ambitious in scope, but no less intense or powerful as a character study and a snapshot of life.
Book Club Questions for Tin Man
· Which character did you like the most, and why?
· Discuss Ellis’s sexuality. How does his understanding of it evolve over time? How relatable or moving did you find his journey?
· How are women represented in the novel compared to men? What role does Annie play, and do you feel her character is fully realised?
· Explore Ellis’s relationship with his father. How does it change after the death of Ellis’s mother? Were you surprised by how it matures by the end of the novel?
· Why does Michael stay away from Oxford for so long?
· The novel explores the AIDS epidemic and the loss and grief surrounding it. How effectively does Winman portray the emotional toll of this period?
· Annie, Ellis’s wife, dies before the main events of the book. How does her absence affect the structure of the narrative and the emotional state of the characters?
· How is art important in the novel, and what role does it play in the characters’ lives?
· What do you think will happen to Ellis in the future?
· Who is your favourite character, and why?
Book Club Questions on Tin Man (For if you haven't read the book)
·
Art
features in the book as a means through which emotions are explored. What art
is important to you, and why?
·
The
novel touches on the AIDS epidemic and its impact. What do you remember about
the AIDS epidemic? How did you understand it at the time? Don’t feel you have
to answer this if it’s too personal or difficult to talk about.
·
The
book is set in Oxford, Brighton, France, and briefly London. What do each of
these places mean to you personally, if anything?
·
Tin
Man is a short book with a non-linear
structure, moving between past and present, and offering multiple perspectives.
What type of narrative structure do you tend to enjoy in fiction?
·
The
book is about people and life rather than a fast-paced plot. What, for you,
makes a compelling story?
· Do you think emotional honesty in writing helps you connect with a story, or do you prefer more escapism in what you read?
· Have you read any books recently that deal with friendship, grief, or identity? How did they compare to other books you’ve enjoyed?