Book Review on Intermezzo by Sally Rooney
Once I knew what it meant, I decided that the title of Intermezzo by Sally Rooney couldn’t have been more fitting. The book Intermezzo is an interlude, a space to pause. Through her writing, Rooney offers us exactly this opportunity. The story is a tender interlude in the lives of two brothers, and for readers, a chance to step into a reflective moment on life’s complexities. We realize that all life’s events, however big or small they seem at the time, are ultimately just a chapter in the relatively small book of our own lives. It’s wonderful in both showing this, yet not making it feel like nothing is ultimately worthwhile.
I have read Rooney’s previous novels (including Normal People), and I found them good—very good, really, I guess in theory, but I was constantly on the verge of feeling that I’d outgrown some of the raw angst her characters typically experience. This one, though, felt different. I listened to Intermezzo on Audible, and there was something about the narrator’s lyrical voice that elevated the story into a class above the rest. The narration was filled with a warmth that brought every interaction and every conversation in the text to life. The book is, if you like, a love letter to the strength of family, the power of grief, and the tangled relationships that make us who we are.
The story centers on two brothers in mourning: Peter, the elder, a fairly successful lawyer (though perhaps not quite as hot-shot as he and those around him believe him to be), whose life appears polished but is layered with hidden messes; and Ivan, a chess-playing genius with a quieter nature and a somewhat strained connection to others. Ivan is often seen by Peter as “on the spectrum,” and the brothers struggle, as brothers do, to bridge their different ways of being in the world. Rooney captures their dynamic beautifully, with all the little hypocrisies—and larger ones—the moments of frustration, and the tender care that seeps through despite everything.
Peter is struggling—his father’s death has up skittled him, and he’s grappling with his own relationships, including a complicated history with an ex-girlfriend and his current relationship with Naomi, a younger woman who embodies a refreshing strength but also makes unconventional choices that challenge Peter’s—and the reader’s—views. Rooney doesn’t give us answers or judgments; instead, she lets us sit with these complexities. Naomi is unapologetically herself, and her relationship with Peter is real and flawed in ways that prompt readers to examine their own perspectives. Peter didn’t plan to fall in love with Naomi; he still loves his ex, and the idea of having both women in his life—exploring something beyond monogamy—fills him with fear, self-loathing, doubt, and uncertainty. And yet… it has its attraction.
Considering Peter’s messy life, it’s perhaps ironic that he is critical of Ivan’s relationship with a much older woman. Yet his intentions are good. Rooney is masterful in creating quiet and not-so-quiet moments where the brothers’ unspoken and spoken judgments and insecurities make themselves known.
The book flows with deeply realistic conversations, each one a brushstroke that paints the brothers’ shared history, love, and individual struggles. Rooney’s talent here is her subtlety, the way she lets us glimpse raw, honest emotions without ever overstating. Listening to their exchanges unfold through the narrator’s voice felt like a privilege; it made the story feel personal, intimate, as though I was a part of something that really mattered.
In the end, Intermezzo is a love story in its own quiet, real way—a story of brotherly love, of grief, and of the connections that, even in their imperfect, messy forms, hold us together. It’s a testament to life’s unpredictable beauty, the interludes that shape us, and the resilience we find in each other. Rooney has created an intermezzo not only for her characters but also for the reader—a pause to reflect on life’s beautiful, complex mess.
Book Club Questions on Sally Rooney's Intermezzo
· How do Peter’s relationships reveal his internal struggles and insecurities in Intermezzo? Discuss how his interactions, particularly with Naomi and his ex-girlfriend, provide insight into his character and the choices he makes.
· The theme of grief runs throughout Intermezzo as both Peter and Ivan deal with the loss of their father. How do their reactions to grief differ, and what does this tell us about their individual characters? Discuss how Rooney portrays the complexities of family in times of loss.
· Do you feel that the use of conversation in Intermezzo adds to the realism of the story, or do you think it was overused? Discuss how Rooney’s reliance on dialogue affects the way the characters are developed and whether it felt authentic to you.
· Naomi uses her body to make money and arguably relies on Peter to provide for her. What are your impressions of her as a character? How do you think Rooney intends readers to feel about Naomi’s choices?
· How does Intermezzo explore the concept of hypocrisy within relationships? Identify a moment where one of the brothers displays hypocrisy, and discuss how this trait adds to the realism of their character.
· Peter is critical of Ivan’s relationship with an older woman, yet he’s incredibly kind when he meets her, Margaret. Why do you think Peter reacts this way? Discuss how this scene shapes our understanding of Peter’s character and intentions.
· What do you think is the most important theme in Intermezzo, and why? Discuss how this theme is developed through the relationships and interactions between characters.
· How does Rooney use small, understated moments to reveal the emotions of the characters in Intermezzo? Pick a line or gesture that struck you and discuss its deeper impact on the story.
· The story is filled with “little hypocrisies—and larger ones.” What do you think these instances say about Rooney’s view of relationships in Intermezzo?
· In Intermezzo, do you think Peter and Ivan have a chance at sustaining happy relationships in the future? Discuss what you think might stand in the way of their long-term happiness.
· The dialogue in Intermezzo often feels intimate, as though we’re overhearing private conversations. How does this use of dialogue shape your perception of Peter and Ivan’s relationship?
· How does Intermezzo create an “intermezzo” for the reader? Do you feel the book allows readers to pause and reflect on their own lives? Discuss the impact this interlude had on you personally.
· In Intermezzo, readers get to know both Peter and Ivan, each with his own strengths and flaws. Which of the two brothers do you think you’d feel more drawn to if you knew them in real life, and why? What qualities make them likable or challenging as characters?
Book Club Questions on Intermezzo (for if you haven't read the book)
· Grief can lead people to act in ways
they normally wouldn’t, sometimes even irrationally. Have you observed grief
affecting people’s behavior in unexpected ways? How do you think grief can
change a person’s relationships with others?
· In Intermezzo, Ivan feels
frustrated when Peter, his brother, takes on the role of delivering their
father’s eulogy. Without pressure to share, does anyone want to discuss a time
when emotions ran high during a funeral or family gathering? How do you think
grief might bring out tensions that were previously under the surface?
· At one point, Peter considers
maintaining relationships with both his ex and his new partner, but he’s
anxious about being seen as “the other.” What does it mean to be
“the other” in relationships or society? How has the idea of “the other”
been treated in literature, and why do you think it matters so much to people?
· A critic might say that “nothing
really happens” in Intermezzo because it’s not heavily plot-driven.
How do you feel about books that focus more on character development and
emotions than on action? Can a story without much plot still be engaging or
meaningful?
· Intermezzo centers on the complex relationship
between two brothers, each coping with loss in his own way. How important do
you think sibling relationships are when it comes to dealing with family
issues? Do you think siblings tend to bring out the best or the worst in each
other during difficult times?